INDIRECT PRESSURE

I have had a lot of questions in reference to “what is indirect pressure?”  The following represents descriptions gathered from a variety of sources including Mike Lardy in his “Training with Mike Lardy” soft cover book based on his articles in the Retriever Journal; from Marilyn Fender’s articles on chaining which were in Online; and from Dennis Voigt in Online.  I strongly recommend subscribing to Retrievers Online Magazine.  It is a tremendous resource regarding training information.

You can find out more by going to www.retrieversonline.com or writing to Retrievers Online, 1457 Heights Rd., Lindsay, ON Canada K9V 4R3.  As of this date, there are three soft cover books on training by Mike Lardy and you can obtain information about their purchase through www.totalretriever.com. 

Indirect pressure is correcting a dog (applying pressure) on a known command for not doing another command.  The classic example is when a dog fails to take a cast correctly and you whistle “sit” and nick the dog with the e-collar before you cast again.  Using indirect pressure probably makes up about 80% of field corrections after the dog has gone through the transition stage.  The whistle “sit” combined with a nick is the vast majority of those corrections.  Direct pressure occurs when you correct a dog on a known command for not doing that behavior.  For example, if a dog is not driving back and you command “back” and nick, that is direct pressure.

The most common indirect pressure commands are with “sit” and with “here”.  An example of using “here” as an indirect pressure is when a dog who has failed to go (no-go) is commanded “here” or “heel” and nicked as you step forward before resending.  (heel-nick-heel)  This is indirect pressure for not going.  Direct pressure would be commanding “back” and nicking.  Generally speaking, indirect pressure has less negative side-effects than direct pressure.  Indirect pressure often resets a chain of behaviors to which dogs respond.  It tends to result in an increase in the desired behavior and thus can be classified as a form of negative reinforcement.  Both Dennis and Marilyn have written some excellent articles about this which were published in Retrievers Online Magazine.

According to Dennis, “Direct pressure often compounds a problem. Indirect pressure often solves and maintains drive and a clear head!!!”

A more complex form of this is when a trainer would apply pressure on one command in one situation in order to get a better response from the dog on a different command or behavior in another situation, at another time.  An example would be to do a force into the water sequence in order to improve control and steadiness at the line.  This sort of indirect pressure can be a much more dangerous form of pressure source as you are relying on strong side effects to be effective.  This takes considerable knowledge and experience.  Used incorrectly, it can create side effects on other behaviors.  This usually should only be done with the assistance of a knowledgeable professional.

According to Marilyn Fender in her articles in Online Magazine, “Indirect pressure is another application of the power of chaining.  To define direct pressure, it is when you correct with pressure a response that is prior to and different from the behavior where the dog has not responded.  The behavior where you apply pressure has been done correctly in the original chain.  While this may seem illogical, in reality it makes a great deal of sense.  The chaining of responses is what causes the correction to be effective.  An example:  a dog no-go’s to a mark---this assumes you have always used a consistent sequence to send your dog.  You would go back to the heel stage of the chain and move forward with heel-nick-heel.  Then you go to the next event in the chain:  sit: put your had down, and then the command to go.  The pressure on heel-nick-heel brings the dog back a few steps into the behavioral chain and moves them back into a known sequence.  In most cases the dog will go for the mark since their names has become not only a release to get the mark, but an automatic response to their name in the learned chain of events.  The results of this sequence will be much more effective than just saying their name over and over or punishing them to get them to go…

It is the same when a dog refuses a cast on a blind.  It is much more effective to use indirect pressure on sit (whistle, nick).  Going back to a “whistle for sit, then nick, puts the dog back into the same chain of behaviors they learned on the double T or in the swim-by.  The whistle means to sit and face the handler, followed by the handler casting and the dog responding correctly…

Teaching chains of behavior to your dog with consistent standards within those chains will increase the effectiveness of your training.”

Another example where indirect pressure can be used is if a dog freezes on a whistle.  Instead of trying to force back, try to get them to break loose with a come-in whistle, then try giving a back or over again.  Here you are using goal displacement---once the dog has frozen on the whistle, your training goal has changed temporarily.  You no longer have to goal of trying to get the blind with the fewest casts and whistles; you want to get the dog to move.

One easily understood description of Indirect Pressure was given by Jerry Harris on the Retriever Training Forum.  It seems to sum it up in a nutshell:

“You send your teenage son to the mailbox.  On the way he spots the neighbor’s voluptuous daughter in a bikini (factor).  He immediately starts in her direction (succumbing to the factor).

You yell (whistle) Son!!!!!! (Handle).  His eyes get back into focus and turns toward you and says “WHAT??”  (responding to the whistle)  For the Amish folks, you walk up to him and whop him upside the head!!! (correction=indirect pressure).  You then say ‘You were told to go get the mail, now do what you were told!!!’

That my friends is Indirect Pressure and why it works.”

***Amish=a trainer who does not use an electric collar.

Return to current Field aritcle